Merchant of record vs payment processor: how solo founders choose
By Tom Baker · 16 November 2026 · 12 min read
A merchant of record is the company that legally sells your product to your customer. It collects and pays sales tax and VAT and handles chargebacks. A payment processor like Stripe only moves the money, so you stay the seller and those jobs stay yours. In return, a merchant of record takes a bigger cut of each sale.
Here's the short verdict on merchant of record vs payment processor. If you sell digital products to consumers in other countries, especially the UK and EU, a merchant of record is usually worth its bigger cut while you're small. It takes on tax registrations you might otherwise need from your first sale.
If your buyers are mostly businesses or mostly in your own country, a processor like Stripe is cheaper and gives you more control.
One honest note: Refund Score works with all six platforms in this guide, so it makes no difference to us which you pick. We'll say further down which one we sell through.
What is a merchant of record?
A merchant of record is the business that legally sells the product to the customer. People often shorten it to MoR.
It works like a reseller. The merchant of record sells your product to your customer, then pays you what's left after its fee and the tax. Its name, often with your product name added, appears on the receipt and the card statement.
For the sales it makes, it takes on:
- Calculating, collecting and paying sales tax and VAT
- Responding to chargebacks (when a customer asks their bank to reverse a payment) and carrying fraud losses
- Card security at checkout, known as PCI, the card industry's security standard
Here's a quick test: whose name is on the receipt? If it's yours, you're the merchant of record.
What it doesn't do is your own income or business taxes, your bookkeeping, your payroll, or the extra rules that come with regulated products. Those stay with you.
Merchant of record vs payment processor: who does what
| Job | Payment processor (such as Stripe) | Merchant of record (such as Paddle) |
|---|---|---|
| Who your customer legally buys from | You | The MoR |
| Name on the card statement | Yours | The MoR's, usually with your product name |
| Tax at checkout | You set it up, for example with an add on such as Stripe Tax | Done for you |
| Tax registration and returns | Yours, everywhere you owe tax | The MoR's, for the sales it makes |
| Chargebacks | You respond, pay the processor's dispute fee and lose the money if the bank sides with the customer | The MoR handles them, so check whether fees are passed on to you |
| Refunds | You issue them under your policy | You usually issue them from the MoR's dashboard, and its buyer terms apply too |
| Card security (PCI) | Mostly covered by the processor's hosted checkout, though you keep some duties | The MoR's |
| Payouts | Rolling schedule to your bank | On the MoR's schedule, so check frequency and minimums |
| Customer and card data | Yours, held by the processor | Held by the MoR, so check export terms |
| Headline fee | Lower | Higher (see fees below) |
People use "payment gateway", "processor" and "merchant of record" as if they're the same thing. A payment gateway for SaaS (software sold as a subscription) is just the part that takes card details at checkout, and SaaS payment processing is the job of moving the money. What matters to you is who the seller is.
Stripe Tax is not a merchant of record. It calculates and collects tax at checkout, but you stay the seller. Registering and filing are still your responsibility, even if you pay a service to do them.
Do you need to deal with sales tax and VAT yet?
Plenty of founders assume they're too small for tax to matter. For US sales tax, that's often true at first. For UK and EU VAT on digital sales, it usually isn't.
US sales tax
Since the Supreme Court's 2018 Wayfair decision, states can require out of state sellers to collect sales tax once they pass an economic nexus threshold (a set level of sales into that state). Many states use $100,000 of sales a year.
Whether SaaS, downloads or courses are taxable at all varies by state. So many small founders owe little or nothing at first, and a processor is often fine.
UK and EU VAT on digital sales
If you're based outside the EU, you must charge VAT on digital services sold to EU consumers from your first sale. There's no threshold. You can register once through the EU's One Stop Shop (the non Union scheme) instead of in each country. EU based sellers get a threshold of €10,000 a year for cross border sales.
The UK is similar. Businesses based outside the UK must register for UK VAT from their first digital sale to a UK consumer, while UK based businesses register once taxable turnover passes £90,000 a year.
Business buyers with a valid VAT number usually account for the VAT themselves, which is called the reverse charge. That's why sellers whose buyers are businesses have far less to do. Consumer VAT from your first sale, not US sales tax, is the main reason merchants of record exist for small sellers.
A five minute check you can do this week
- Export the last three months of sales by country.
- Split consumer buyers from business buyers.
- Look at consumer sales outside your home country.
If that last number is real, it's a merchant of record signal. If it's close to zero, a processor is probably fine for now.
These are general rules, not tax advice. An accountant who knows digital sales can confirm your position.
Stripe vs Paddle, Lemon Squeezy, Polar, Dodo Payments and Creem
If you're looking at Stripe alternatives because of tax, the five merchants of record below are the usual shortlist.
Headline fees side by side
| Platform | Merchant of record? | Headline fee | Extras to check |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stripe | No, payment processor | 2.9% + 30¢ per domestic card (US account); 1.5% + 20p for standard UK cards (UK account) | International cards, currency conversion, Stripe Tax and Stripe Billing cost extra |
| Paddle | Yes | 5% + 50¢ | Larger sellers can ask for custom pricing |
| Lemon Squeezy | Yes | 5% + 50¢ | Extra fees can apply to some payments |
| Polar | Yes | 5% + 50¢ (Starter plan) | A Pro plan lowers the rate for a monthly fee; payouts have their own small fee |
| Dodo Payments | Yes | 4% + 40¢ | International payments, PayPal and subscriptions add a little |
| Creem | Yes | 3.9% + 40¢ | Revenue splits with partners cost extra |
Fees checked: November 2026. Rates change often, so check each platform's own pricing page. Headline rates only: your real rate depends on card type, country and currency, so confirm the current rate before you sign up.
A disclosure: we sell Refund Score through Creem. That's our choice for our own product, not a ranking, and Refund Score works with all six.
What the fixed fee does to a cheap product
Every fee above has two parts: a percentage and a fixed amount per sale. The fixed part bites hardest on cheap products.
On headline rates, a $9 template costs about 56¢ in fees on Stripe US (6.2% of the price) and 95¢ on Paddle (10.6%). A $99 course costs about $3.17 on Stripe (3.2%) and $5.45 on Paddle (5.5%).
The Stripe figure leaves out tax, billing and international card extras, so the real gap is smaller than it looks.
Where each platform fits
- Stripe gives you the most control. You can send invoices and agree custom deals with business buyers. Your customer and card data is yours, held by Stripe. You're the seller, so tax registration and filing are yours. It fits best when your buyers are businesses or mostly close to home. Stripe has also started offering its own merchant of record service, Stripe Managed Payments, for an extra fee on top of its normal rates. At the time of writing it isn't open to every account, so check whether you can use it.
- Paddle is a long established merchant of record built around software and SaaS subscriptions. It takes on tax and chargebacks for the sales it makes, so it suits founders selling subscription software to buyers in many countries who'd rather not register for VAT and sales tax in each one themselves.
- Lemon Squeezy is a merchant of record for digital products, courses and SaaS, with a hosted storefront and licence keys built in. Stripe has owned it since 2024, and its team now works on Stripe Managed Payments, so it's worth watching where it heads. Paddle vs Lemon Squeezy is where many indie founders start their comparison, especially if they sell downloads too.
- Polar is an open source merchant of record aimed at developers. It handles subscriptions and usage based billing (charging for what customers use), and its benefits can deliver licence keys, file downloads and GitHub repository access automatically. That makes it handy if you sell a boilerplate.
- Dodo Payments is a merchant of record for SaaS, AI and digital products. It supports subscriptions, usage and credit based billing, single purchases and licence keys, so it can cover a product that mixes monthly plans with paying for what you use.
- Creem is a merchant of record aimed at indie hackers and micro SaaS, meaning small software products often run by one or two people. It's worth a look if you're shipping small tools on your own and want the tax side handled from the start.
Refunds, chargebacks and the name on your customer's statement
With a merchant of record, the charge shows on your customer's card statement under the MoR's name, usually with your product name added. An unfamiliar name is exactly how "I don't recognise this" disputes start.
The fix is small. Say on your checkout page and in your receipt email exactly what name will appear. Make your refund policy and a contact address easy to find. Our guide to building trust with customers online has more on this.
Customers buying through an MoR can also contact it directly, and its buyer terms sit alongside yours. Read the refund part of those terms before you write your own policy, so the two agree. An easy refund is kinder than a chargeback, for the customer and for you.
Whichever platform you choose, your refunds and disputes are already in its data. Reviews tell you how people felt. Refunds tell you what they did.
Refund Score turns that data into a verified star rating you can show your visitors as a badge. The score behind the stars is 100 minus the percentage of sales that were refunded or disputed, rounded to the nearest 10 and shown in half stars, and it needs at least 10 sales.
It works with all six platforms in this guide. Chargebacks count where the platform reports them. Lemon Squeezy doesn't report them, so there the score comes from refunds.
The colour of the stars shows how many sales are behind them, from 10+ up to 10k+. Five stars on 100 sales is great. Five stars on 5,000 sales is a flex. Here's how to read a Refund Score in full.
Scores stay private until you subscribe and verify you own your website. We store counts only, never customer names, emails or amounts.
Can you switch payment platforms later?
Yes, but plan for it before you sign up, not after. These are the questions to put to any platform while you're still choosing:
- Ask whether they'll export card data to another PCI compliant provider, or whether your subscribers will have to enter their cards again.
- Ask how you export customer emails and sales history.
- Check what happens to active subscriptions and licence keys if you leave.
- Confirm how you'll get tax and payout records for the part of the year you were with them.
Platforms also change hands. Stripe bought Lemon Squeezy in 2024, so choosing with a way out in mind is simply sensible.
One habit to start this week: export your customers and sales every month, whatever you use. If you ever do move, you'll already have everything you need.
Merchant of record or Stripe: which should you choose?
Find the row that sounds most like you. The fees and tax rules behind each answer are in the sections above.
| If this is you | Start with |
|---|---|
| You sell to consumers in many countries and never want to file a VAT return | A merchant of record |
| Most buyers are businesses, and you send invoices or do custom deals | Stripe |
| Most buyers are in your own country and you're under local thresholds | Stripe, adding a tax tool when you need it |
| Your products sell for just a few dollars each | Compare fixed fees on your actual price |
| You sell a developer tool or a boilerplate with repo access | Polar |
| You run subscription SaaS and sell worldwide | Compare Paddle, Dodo Payments and Creem |
| You want a hosted store for downloads and courses | Lemon Squeezy, or any MoR with a storefront |
Three checks before you commit to any of them:
- Run a test purchase in test mode, from checkout through to the receipt email.
- Read the buyer terms and the list of products the platform won't accept. Every merchant of record reviews your product before approving you.
- Check the payout schedule and work out the fee on your real price.
Once payments work, the next thing your visitors wonder is whether you're legit. That's where trust badges that actually prove something come in.
If you already have sales on any of these six platforms, you can check your stars free, no sign up needed. It's a quick look at what your refunds and disputes already say.
Your first payment platform doesn't have to be your last. Pick the one that fits the buyers you have this month, and get back to building.
Merchant of record FAQs
Is Stripe a merchant of record?
Not with standard Stripe. You're the merchant of record and Stripe processes the payment. Your business is the seller, so sales tax, VAT, refunds and chargebacks are your responsibility. Stripe Tax can calculate and collect tax at checkout, but it doesn't change who the seller is. Registering for tax and filing returns still sit with you. Stripe Managed Payments, a newer extra cost service, does make Stripe the seller, where it's available.
Is PayPal a merchant of record?
Not with a normal PayPal checkout. In that setup, you're the merchant of record and PayPal processes the payment, so tax, refunds and disputes are yours to handle. If you take PayPal through a merchant of record, the MoR is the seller, and PayPal is simply one of the ways your customer can pay it.
What is the difference between a PayFac and a merchant of record?
A payment facilitator, or PayFac, such as Stripe signs you up under its own master merchant account, so you can take cards quickly without opening your own. You still remain the seller, responsible for tax, refunds and chargebacks. A merchant of record is the legal seller of your product, so it takes on tax and chargebacks for the sales it makes.
Do I still need an accountant if I use a merchant of record?
Yes. A merchant of record handles sales tax and VAT on the sales it makes, but not your own income or business taxes, your bookkeeping or payroll. An accountant can help you record the MoR's payouts correctly, since they arrive with fees and tax already taken off, and confirm whether you have other tax duties where you're based.
Can I switch from Stripe to a merchant of record later?
Yes, many founders do. Before you move, plan for three things: whether card data can move to the new provider or subscribers must enter their cards again, what happens to active subscriptions and licence keys, and how you'll keep tax and payout records for the year. Ask the new platform how it handles moves, and export your customers and sales first.
Who handles refunds when you use a merchant of record?
You usually issue refunds yourself from the merchant of record's dashboard, and the MoR processes the money back to the customer. Its buyer terms apply alongside your own refund policy, and customers can contact it directly too. Refunds still show in your sales data, so you can always see how many you issue compared with your total sales.
More from the blog
Ahrefs DR4: what changes on 1 December (we checked 101 sites)
Ahrefs replaces Domain Rating with DR4 on 1 December 2026. We checked 101 sites on both versions: launch directories lost a median of 17 points.
11 social proof examples for SaaS, courses and indie sellers
Social proof examples for SaaS, courses and small online businesses, grouped by type, with a note on which ones visitors can check and which they ignore.
How to build credibility as a new SaaS or course creator
How to build credibility for a new SaaS, course or boilerplate with no track record: real proof visitors can check, honest testimonials and what to skip.